Skip to content

Marketing

How to Measure Marketing Performance in a Small Business? Which KPIs Really Matter?

A store owner has a ROAS of 4, yet at the end of the month they are topping up the business from their savings. We explain why popular metrics mislead, which KPIs tell the truth about profit and how to calculate them in a small business.

Illustration of an online business's results: a chart symbol with rising results next to a laptop.

A store has a ROAS of 4. For every 1 PLN spent on ads, it makes 4 PLN in sales. On paper it looks great. The owner is happy, the campaign works, the budget grows, and the company account gets quieter and quieter. A year later they are topping up the business from their private savings.

The advertising works well. What fails is what the company measures. ROAS, revenue and website traffic are easy to put in a report, but none of them says how much money is left after all costs. Some metrics can mislead, while others let you make sound decisions about growing the business.

Metrics that look good but can be misleading

ROAS

ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) shows how much in sales an ad generated: you spend 1 PLN, you sell for 4 PLN. It does not take into account margin, operating costs or returns. You can have a ROAS of 4 and lose money on every order you ship.

Revenue

"We made fifty thousand this month" sounds good at a meeting with a partner. But revenue says nothing about profit or the cost of acquiring customers. If you spend sixty thousand on ads to sell fifty thousand worth of goods, you have a problem. High revenue with a low margin is a faster road to a loss.

Website traffic

More visits do not automatically mean more money. Thousands of visits from people who don't intend to buy are just a number in the analytics panel. What matters is the intent with which a user lands on the site, not the number of visits alone. In a small business, every zloty spent on traffic should translate into sales.

KPIs that decide profit

Profit per order

This is the order's revenue minus all the costs you attribute to it: the product, shipping, advertising and service. If the result is negative, every next order deepens the loss, no matter how fast sales grow.

Take an order worth 300 PLN and subtract step by step:

  • goods: 120 PLN,
  • shipping: 18 PLN,
  • packaging (box, filler, label): 6 PLN,
  • payment fee: 7 PLN,
  • the ad that brought in the customer: 75 PLN (this is exactly ROAS 4),
  • returns (one in ten parcels comes back): 12 PLN,
  • customer service, tools, electricity: 15 PLN.

That leaves 47 PLN. This is what you earn on one order, not the margin from the price tag and not ROAS. Most owners count only goods and advertising. The remaining costs quietly eat the profit, month after month, until it turns out there is no money for salaries.

CAC and LTV

CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost) is the cost of acquiring one customer. LTV (Lifetime Value) is the profit a customer leaves in the company over time. Together they answer the question of whether the business model can scale.

Back to the example. From a 300 PLN order, 122 PLN is left before you add advertising (178 PLN goes to goods, shipping, packaging, payment, returns and service). Suppose acquiring a new customer costs 150 PLN. The advertising cost per order from the previous example is an average that also includes orders from returning customers, and a new customer costs more. So after the first purchase you are 28 PLN short of zero. If the customer comes back after four months, the next order has no advertising cost and again leaves about 122 PLN. Only then do you come out ahead.

In stores with a lot of repeat purchases, recovering the acquisition cost within 6-9 months is a reasonable goal (this is an industry benchmark, not a rule). When it takes more than a year, cash flow becomes the problem, even if the company earns money on paper.

LTV without a time horizon means nothing. "A customer is worth 400 PLN" sounds good, but it doesn't say whether you wait a month or five years for that money. Say: "a customer leaves 400 PLN over two years". Steady value from a single customer is built, among other ways, with a subscription model.

Conversion rate

Analyse conversion separately for each channel, campaign and product, not as a single number for the whole site. Two percent from an ad campaign and two percent from organic traffic mean different things. Only such a breakdown shows where to add budget and where to cut it. You can set up the channel breakdown in Google Analytics 4.

AOV - average order value

AOV shows whether customers want to spend more with you. It is one of the easier metrics to improve:

  • product bundles (when a bundle beats a discount),
  • upsell, i.e. a more expensive version of what the customer is already looking at,
  • cross-sell, i.e. complementary products,
  • a free-shipping threshold.

It is cheaper to raise the order value for a customer who is already with you than to acquire new ones every month.

Repeat Purchase Rate

Do customers who bought once come back? If not, the cause may be the product, the buying experience or a lack of communication after the sale. If so, you have a foundation for scaling. Ask yourself two questions:

  • How many days pass on average between the first and the second purchase?
  • How many of January's customers came back by April?

With rare repeat purchases, scaling through ads only speeds up the burning of cash. Post-purchase emails, loyalty programs and a marketing funnel planned for after the sale also help bring customers back.

An analysis by Bain & Company is often cited here: raising customer retention by 5 percentage points increases profit by 25-95%, depending on the industry. This data comes from the 1990s, mostly from services, so treat it as a direction, not a forecast for your store. The logic is simple, though: a returning customer doesn't require another ad payment.

How KPIs connect with each other

The biggest mistake is looking at metrics separately. For example: ROAS falls, AOV rises, LTV rises. The end result may be that profit grows despite "worse" ad results. If you focus only on ROAS, you may switch off the campaign that attracts the most valuable customers.

Most common mistakes of small business owners

  • optimising for ROAS instead of profit,
  • acquiring new customers at the expense of those who have already bought,
  • ignoring margin when setting prices,
  • no segmentation: treating all customers and orders the same.

Minimum KPIs at the end of the month

You don't need to roll out advanced analytics right away. It is enough to answer four questions every month:

  1. How much is left from one order after all costs?
  2. How much does it cost to acquire one customer?
  3. Do customers come back and buy again?
  4. Is the average basket value growing?

If you don't know the answer to any of these questions, calculate your last ten orders. That is enough to see where the company is losing money.

Summary

ROAS, revenue and traffic show what is happening on the site. Profit is shown by profit per order, CAC, LTV, AOV and the repeat purchase rate. Start with the four questions from the previous section and calculate your latest orders. Make advertising budget decisions based on these numbers, not on ROAS alone.

Share

Related articles

Is this about your business?

We'll take a look at how this applies to you and what can be done about it. No-obligation conversation.